This transcript was produced using AI and it may contain errors.
In the recent film, Sheep Detective, we are given imaginative insight into the
life of a flock of sheep who has their shepherd murdered. This movie is a
murder mystery following the actions of the investigators, the sheep
detectives. In the film, we see what it looks like for a flock to be sheep
without a shepherd. They struggle with the murder of their shepherd. They are
easily taken advantage of, misdirected, easily harmed and hurt. And throughout
the movie, you are playfully carried along to see their need for a shepherd. We
too, the people of God, are a flock who has had not their shepherd murdered,
but having their shepherd killed, whose death was not a mystery, was planned in
history. And though he died, he still lives, and he serves as the great
shepherd of the church. But he's entrusted his flock to under shepherds, men
who will care, lead and feed his flock until he comes again. Throughout the Old
and New Testament, we see that God refers to his people as sheep, and he has
set his leaders over them as shepherds. With reference to God's church, it's no
different. He has set over his church, his flock, overseers or elders to
shepherd his flock, to care for them, lead them and feed them. In this text
this morning, Paul tells us who these shepherds should be. Above all, they
should be men who are called, men who have character and men of competency.
This is not to say that elders will be perfect. However, they are to be
exemplary. Some of you may have grown up in churches where you did not have
elders, like myself. You may have heard the term, and you know what they are,
but maybe you don't see their value. Some of you have grown up in churches with
elders, but you don't see how crucial they are. And my hope this morning is
that we would see the need for godly elders, how they are for our good, and how
they reflect Christ as the cheap shepherd of the church. Like in the movie,
there are nefarious actors who come to try and co-opt the flock for themselves.
And we have seen this in the book of 1 Timothy, but there are false teachers
who have come in and tried to lead the flock astray. It is into this context
that Paul speaks these qualifications. So the leaders in the church of Ephesus
and the church down through the ages will be men who rightly reflect Christ to
the congregation and the world. This morning we will see that the church is to
be led by Christ-like elders who are men who are called, men of character, and
men who are competent. Before we look at our first point, some of you might
feel like I'm mixing and matching my words. You might feel confused with the
terms that I'm using. I'm switching between shepherd, elder, overseer, and I'm
using them interchangeably. Despite our text that is before you, using the word
overseer. The reason I'm doing this is because the New Testament does so. You
can see in your bulletin there are three other passages in the New Testament
where elders, overseers, and shepherds are referred to. And what we see is that
Paul and Peter use these terms interchangeably. John Stott notes likely that
the word overseer, which is the Greek word episkopos, is drawing upon a
Greco-Roman formality that was known at that time. Whereas the word elder or
prosbyteros is drawing upon the Jewish tradition of elders in the synagogue.
And the term pastor or poiumen or shepherd is used to speak of what or how an
elder is to function among the flock of God. Throughout church history, some
have believed that overseer refers to a different office in the church. In the
Latin, the word overseer is translated as bishop. And some have believed that
bishops are different and distinct than an elder. But even in our short survey
that you've seen this morning, you'd see that overseer, pastor, and elder are
one and the same. In our denomination, we believe that there are only two
offices in the church, elder and deacon. Elders are given to the ministry of
the word and prayer, and deacons are given to the work of service in the church
and community. We see this at the beginning of the church in Acts chapter 6,
which we will revisit next week as we discuss elders. As well as in our
tradition, we differentiate between ruling elders and teaching elders. I and
the elders of this church serve with the same authority and responsibilities,
but we differ in function. We are to be given to the spiritual oversight,
guarding of doctrine, and exercising discipline. But as a teaching elder, I
have the unique set-apart responsibility to teach the flock, to preach God's
word, and to preside over the sacraments. Effectually, teaching elders are
called pastor or minister. As a teaching elder, I am examined by our presbytery
to see if I have become qualities and character of an elder, whether I am
competent to teach the scriptures, and whether I have been trained adequately
to hold this office. For our ruling elders, they are men who do the work
non-vocationally, meaning that they do this voluntarily. It's not their job,
but it is their calling to provide the oversight, the guarding of doctrine, and
the exercise of discipline. Simply put, we share the same office, but differ in
function. This is not a differentiation that we have somehow come up with for
the sake of convenience. We want to just somehow pay a guy to take up the brunt
of the work, and we want to sort of have something else. That is not the case.
This is based on 1 Timothy, chapter 5, verse 17. I did not put that in your
bulletin, but you can flip there just a page over in your Bible, and you'd see
that Paul says, Paul makes clear that there are ruling and teaching elders in
this verse. And the qualifications that are given here apply to both ruling and
teaching elders. This morning, this text is like a magnifying glass and mirror
to us as elders, as we see the ways in which we are excelling in areas where we
are failing. This text also serves to consider who God has set apart to be an
elder, whether teaching or ruling. God, I really do believe God uses moments
like this to clarify calling in the lives of his people. But he also uses texts
like this to teach his church to know who they see having these gifts amongst
the congregation and seek for them to lead in these offices. There will be a
day for us to pick more ruling elders or for us to hire another pastor in our
church. What we should see is that God has given us the grid of evaluation. He
has told us that these men should be one who are called, men of character, and
men who are competence. And so let us turn our attention to our first point,
looking at verse 1 of chapter 3, that these men are to be called. Paul tells
Timothy, the men who serve as elders or overseers should aspire and desire the
noble task. They should desire and aspire to the noble task of being an
overseer. This is what most people mean when they use the term, internal sense
of calling. The man should want to be an elder, wanting to oversee the souls of
the church, caring for them as a shepherd, leading them, teaching them, loving
them, encouraging them, binding up, correcting them. The list of work and tasks
that an elder should do is robust. If someone is to be an elder, they should
feel called to this. First Peter uses the same language. Peter says that an
elder should not serve under compulsion, but willingly. I would argue,
wantingly. And if this is not the case, then a man should not serve as an
elder. He can be a good teacher, he can be a man of great character, or he can
even be a great manager. But if he does not want to be in the office, he lacks
these qualifications. He is automatically not to be considered. The man who is
to be an elder should share in the heart of Christ in Matthew 9, verse 36,
where Jesus sees the people and has compassion, seeing that they are sheep
without a shepherd. And he sees their need and seeks to respond. There are men
who want some aspect of the task, but not the whole. However, you can't just
somehow be partly an elder and just do part of the job. While I was in
seminary, I heard more than once, which is concerning, and this should be
concerning for us, I heard men say, I love preaching, but I hate people. Or, I
love teaching, but I hate counseling. I understand that men will not be equally
gifted in all aspects of being an elder. But if you do not care for the flock,
there is no business in being an elder. We take seriously when someone desires
this office. However, that desire should be examined. There are bad reasons
that people want to be elders, for bad reasons that people want to be pastors.
Instead of wanting to care for people, there are men who are obsessed with
power and authority and try and posture and position themselves to somehow
acquire it wrongfully. The sad reality is that this does happen. There are many
men who become pastors and elders in this world who rather should not have been
chosen, who should not have been put in those positions of authority. In a
matter of time, their deficiencies and inadequacies do get revealed. Paul
concludes in verses 6 and 7 how they are exposed. They are exposed with pride
and they are exposed with disgrace. Pride is like bad breath. Everyone knows
you have it except yourself. But people know. And disgrace, if your character
is faulty, it will come out. Just a matter of time when your character will be
exposed. A man can grow in competency and he can grow in character. But
competency is more like a muscle that can be trained over time. Whereas
character is identity and identity needs to be changed by God. But to be the
office of elder, it begins with calling. Do you desire the noble task? The work
of overseeing souls, of caring for sheep, that is where qualifications begin.
If a man desires to serve as an elder, I'd encourage you, if you were here this
morning, to see where that desire is rooted. Is it truly rooted in the
motivation of a shepherd? Or is it elsewhere? And continue from there, I'd
encourage you to examine your character and competencies as we will explore in
our next two points. For our existing elders, I encourage you to remember your
calling. To examine it and recenter it. It's easy for us to stay in this office
for time and say, I just have to do it since I'm an elder. And brothers, that's
not the case. It's not that we have to do it. We get to do it. We have a
privilege of shepherding God's flock. And may we do this willfully. For you as
a congregation, this is a call to discernment. Would you be reminded afresh
that God has set elders over you? And when you do consider individuals in this
church, in the future, consider if they are called. Do they rightly desire the
task? Do they understand the task? These things matter so much. So would we not
brush them off thinking, well, I'm not an elder, so why does this matter to me?
In our constitution, it is your right as a congregation to identify who your
officers are. And if you do this well, you will see men who are raised up to
the office who care for the flock well, upholding the task and upholding their
calling. Let's move to our second point, character. Paul tells us that an elder
should be above reproach. This means that he should not be open. He should not
have open charges of unrepentant sin or have public accusations against him.
Paul gives a list of 10 qualities where an elder should be seen as above
reproach. That he would be free from accusations in the area of personal
purity, of mental and emotional restraint. That he would be a man who welcomes
outsiders. That he would live a life of sobriety. That he would be gentle with
his words and his actions. That he would be able to have a conversation and not
have it devolve into an argument. That he would be able to have ordered loves
in his heart that the things of this world do not ensnare him. These qualities
listed here are qualities that I hope each one of us embody in our lives.
However, if you are an elder or hope to be an elder or live an elder qualified
life, you must see that your character must be exemplary. Given the time that
we have this morning, I want to avoid over explaining what is clear in this
passage. Such as words like respectable. I think we all know what respectable
means. But I do want to clarify three characteristics that have been
historically misunderstood. Those are the husband of one wife, being hospitable
and being gentle. Paul here articulates that a man should be above reproach as
an elder. That he should be a husband of one wife or one woman man. In this,
Paul is not disqualifying unmarried men, nor is he barring those who are
rightly divorced and remarried, or those who are widowers and remarried. Paul
is articulating that a man should exemplify sexual fidelity. If he is married,
then he is faithful to his wife. If he is single, he is faithful to his
celibacy. Though it would have been normative for men to be married in this
office of elder, there are clearly exceptions to this norm. Paul was not
married. Timothy was likely unmarried. Jesus, who is the great shepherd of the
flock, is unmarried. And so what we see is that an unmarried man can yes be an
elder. It is possible. We've seen this in church history. However, if someone
is wrongfully divorced, if someone is sexually promiscuous, in person or
online, engaging with multiple women as his wife, he is not qualified to be an
elder. Similarly, if an elder participates in any of these sins, he is
disqualified himself. The sad reality is that this does take place today in
Christ Church, where men disqualify themselves from the office of elder for
their actions and their sins. Can these men be repentant and still be
Christians? Yes. But I would argue that they should not be restored to the
office of elder. There are men in our culture today who are writing books and
trying to somehow co-opt and come back to the pulpit after committing heinous
sins. And would we see this and say that that is wrong? That is inappropriate.
Can they still be a Christian? Yes. Should they be an office or no? As I say
all this, you might be still wondering, can a man be childless and be an elder?
And just as someone can be unmarried in the office, yes, someone can be
childless. What Paul has in view, I'd argue, is that he is looking at, does
this man, in his leadership, does he exhibit dignity for those who are in his
charge and lead them well? For if one is a father, we must ask, does he deal
with his children in a way that degrades them? Does he lead others and do
others follow him? Or does children follow him? When he speaks, does he
belittle or does he build up? There should be a manner in the way that he
speaks and leads that is ministering and caring for that individual where they
are and is leading them to where they should be. For a man without children, we
should evaluate this with his disciples. Does he lead in a way that has men and
women in fear and despair? Does he lead people and do they actually follow him?
Does he actually speak with dignity towards them? Regardless if a man has
children or not, it will be exposed whether he is a good manager or if he
isn't. And so we should see this in a man's life. Now let us turn our attention
to hospitality. The word that is underneath this, that is translated as
hospitable, is phylo-zenotha, to love strangers. As much as I want my home and
our elders' homes to be filled with those in our church, what Paul has in mind
is those who are outsiders, those who are not within the church. Those people
you don't know well. Elsewhere in scripture it says that it is easy for a man
to love those whom he already does love, but how does he treat an outsider? Who
they welcomed and cared for in their presence? Are they hostile towards
outsiders? Christians are called in hospitality to value love and encourage
those around them to exemplify Christ through their actions. In welcoming
strangers, we are embodying Christ who welcomes us despite us being sinners.
Lastly, let us look at being gentle. To be gentle, and I think I have said this
before, Paul Tripp says it is to not disturb something that is in process. I
think of this like a CD player, if you don't know what a CD player is, maybe I
have shown my age, but if you move a CD in a CD player, you will scratch it.
And when we speak and act, we must ask, do our words fit the occasion? Does
this not mean that an elder does not say difficult things, such as words of
correction? Instead, this call to be above reproach in gentleness is to examine
how they say these things. Do they say this as the aim of rehabilitation and
restoration of an individual? Or instead, is there retaliation and ruin at the
end of their words? And the end of their actions? This plays out how an elder
holds a disagreement. The aim is not to win an argument. Instead, it is to
shepherd, teach, and care. Paul will later say to rebuke others with all
patience, denoting the fact that people don't change on our timelines. Instead,
it points towards a long-suffering bearing with one another. And so for the
elders in this room, the potential elders in the future, and for you as a
congregation, we want to see men who look most like Jesus to lead his church.
Growing in Christ-likeness is only possible by faith and repentance and
entrusting ourselves to Christ to change us and conform us to His image from
the inside out. Because regardless of how long someone has been walking with
the Lord, we all have the propensity to become puffed up with conceit and fall
short amongst outsiders. The humility and consistency of a man's character in
this office only comes from the outside. It comes by Christ. Because left to
our own devices, we will all fall short. We need Christ to change our character
and consistently keep our character, which will lead us to be like Him. Lastly,
let's look at our third point, that elders should be men of competency. The
characteristics that are outlined here lead to action, particularly in
teaching. An elder is called to walk the walk and talk the talk. In this, he is
called to teach others to do also. In 1 Timothy, Paul provides a more elaborate
explanation of how an elder should teach. He says this, that he is to hold fast
to the trustworthy word as he has been taught, which is the gospel, that he
should be able to give instruction and sound doctrine, being able to rebuke
those who contradict it. The teaching of an elder is twofold. It is to instruct
and exhort. It tells you clearly what God's word has said, and it tells us
where we have fallen short. In this action, we see it is an act of even
discipline in the church when elders do the work of teaching, showing what is
false and what is true. This is where it begins. We believe in church
discipline. It begins with exhortation. If someone is falling short in this
church, it is an elder's job to come and be like, brother or sister? According
to God's word, this does not accord and befit a Christian. I call you to
repent. And if they continue on in that, then there are ways in which we should
respond according to Matthew 18, as I outlined a few weeks ago. In this, we see
why an elder should be a good manager, how that should be exemplified in his
home. That is the other mark of competency. It's teaching, but it's also
managing. One that seems a mark of competency that is not as clear in this
text, but I want to bring forward to us, is maturity. An elder should be a man
who is mature in his faith. This does not mean that an elder cannot be young.
Instead, it's emphasizing how an elder should be established in his faith. He
should be able to walk the walk and talk the talk. Similar to how we would be
cautious of leaving our car with someone who has been a mechanic for a month,
so should we be cautious of leaving our souls to be cared for by a new convert.
The competency of an elder should be exemplified in his teaching, but it's
embodied in his life. The same way in Karate Kid that Mr. Miyagi gives Daniel a
variety of tasks that at face value don't seem to be teaching Daniel Karate, so
does God use ordinary means in the life of men to see and build them to be
faithful elders. In Karate Kid, when Daniel finally realizes that these tasks
that Mr. Miyagi has given him actually are karate moves, so too is it with
faithful character that leads us to faithful elders. The list of
characteristics and competencies given here in many ways are ordinary
qualities, but are to be lived in extraordinary ways. Not that elders are
perfect, however, that their lives are an example to the flock, saying with our
lives and with our words that we can say, imitate me as I imitate Christ. The
character qualities of an elder are to point beyond ourselves, to point to
someone who we naturally are not, and that is Christ. It is only being with him
and in him that we can exemplify any of these qualities, let alone one. Will
there be times and areas where failure exists? Yes. But the question is, to
what degree has that person failed, and what are they doing with that failure?
Are they repentant, seeking to turn from whatever sin it is, or are they
obstinate, showing no fruit of repentance? The godly elder will be a man of
repentance modeling seeking forgiveness. And in this, it points us to the Great
Shepherd himself, Jesus Christ. In this, elders are not just a model of Christ,
but they model and show us, all of us, our need for a Savior. The righteous
life of an elder will not save himself or the church. Instead, it is Christ and
Christ alone, in whom we all must trust. To know this life is not just to be
seen in the shepherds of this church, but it is life with the true Shepherd
himself, Jesus Christ. Though we do not see him, he is still leading, guiding,
providing, feeding, and teaching each one of us, till he calls us home, or he
comes again. But in the meantime, he is given under shepherds to care for you,
and to love you, and to guide you. And with this, we trust both. God's designed
for the church, but ultimately trusting Christ, who has designed the church.